If you've spent any time on LinkedIn or X over the last week, you'd be forgiven for thinking generative AI in advertising is dead on arrival.
This Christmas, almost every major brand has deliberately gone the other way, leaning heavily into visible human craft as an antidote to a year drowning in synthetic content. John Lewis built a puppet dog, Barbour and Thatchers called in Aardman, Levi's went with claymation, and Prada opted for hand-drawn animation. It seems that the view is - when anyone can generate a video in seconds, showing real human effort signals that a brand actually cares.
And then there's Coca-Cola.
For the third year running, Coke has defied the creative industry's fury and rolled out another AI-generated version of its iconic *Holidays Are Coming* advert. Opening with Santa cracking open a glass bottle and placing a miniature toy truck onto a snowy model village road, the 2026 spot landed in prime-time UK ad breaks during *Gogglebox*-and right on cue, the comment sections erupted.
Personally, I'm torn on this one. In our house, the original Coke truck adverts are practically sacred. Coca-Cola is my wife's favourite drink, she owns a small collection of Christmas jumpers covered in those illuminated red trucks, and she sings *"Holidays Are Coming"* more than any actual Christmas carol throughout November and December.
When Coke first used AI to remake the ad a couple of years ago, I got it. They wanted to be seen as innovative and push what the tech could do-fair enough. Rolling out essentially the same AI execution three years in a row, though, just feels lazy from a creative standpoint. Worse still, stripping the humans out of the story and replacing them with overly cute AI animals misses the entire magic that made the original special in the first place: the young boy ringing the bell to alert everybody and then running to watch with the whole town stepping outside in genuine awe of the spectacle of the coke trucks…
So why would one of the most sophisticated marketing machines on the planet keep doubling down on a format that feels creatively hollow-and gets roasted online every November?
The massive gap between Twitter outrage and the living room sofa
Because the internet is not real life, and consumer testing proves it.
In a sharp breakdown for *The Drum*, System1's Andrew Tindall shared how the 2026 AI advert actually performed when tested with a representative sample of everyday British consumers. The numbers tell a completely different story to your social feed:
2024 AI Remake: Scored 5.9 Stars (System1's maximum rating).
2025 Follow-Up: Scored 5.9 Stars again.
2026 Edition: Scored 5.7 Stars.
When real people sit down with a cup of tea to watch TV, 68% of them feel genuine happiness watching the ad-nearly double the average for a UK TV commercial. Active dislike sits at just 5%, completely in line with the national baseline.
While I miss the human warmth of the original ad, the average viewer sitting on their sofa isn't dissecting creative originality or noticing that the townspeople have been swapped for woodland creatures. They hear the jingle, see the red trucks rolling through the snow, and get that familiar hit of festive nostalgia.
Why vocal minorities skew marketing decisions
As marketers, we spend our days trapped inside an echo chamber of designers, copywriters, tech critics, and chronically online commentators. When a few thousand people pile onto a post calling an ad "soulless," it feels like a nationwide boycott.
In reality, 5% or 6% of a mass-market audience is more than enough people to fill every comment section in the country. Hate travels faster and louder than a casual viewer thinking, *"Oh nice, the Coke ad is back."*
If AI-generated trucks were actually hurting sales or damaging brand equity in Atlanta, Coca-Cola would have parked them in a garage two years ago. They brought them back for a third run because the underlying brand assets-the music, the red, the trucks-do the heavy lifting regardless of how the frames were rendered.
What this means for your own brand campaigns
This doesn't mean every business should rush out and replace their creative team with AI prompts tomorrow. Coca-Cola can get away with creative laziness because they are coasting on thirty years of deeply embedded cultural memory-enough to put a convoy of red trucks on Christmas jumpers decades later. If a smaller brand without that heritage puts out generic AI video, audiences will scroll right past it, or worse, assume you took cheap shortcuts.
The takeaway here is about measurement and perspective:
Separate social noise from commercial reality: Never mistake a loud comment section for what your actual paying customers think. This isn’t me saying ignore comments. But put them in perspective of the wider reality.
Protect your distinctive brand assets: Coca-Cola's ad works because its sonic and visual codes are unmistakable. Even a watered-down remake still triggers decades of built-up affection.
Don't mistake novelty for strategy: Using AI once to experiment is fine, but leaning on it repeatedly without a real human story at the centre is a quick way to erode what made your brand special in the first place.